2010 FB Mock Draft
Dec 5th, 2009 by winabango
Welcome to the official page of the 2010 Fantasy Baseball Mock Draft. Throughout the next month 14 “owners” will be drafting a 23-man roster as a preview for the 2010 MLB season. Be sure to follow along as the draft progress and offer your opinion as each round is posted to the site.
Let the 2010 Fantasy Baseball Mock Draft Begin…
Round 1 - View Comments
- Harrell Kirstein - Hanley Ramirez - SS, FLA
- Rick Hoffman - Albert Pujols - 1B, STL
- Dennis Page - Miguel Cabrera - 1B, DET
- Dan Kercher - Carl Crawford - OF, TB
- Jim Halberg - Chase Utley - 2B, PHI
- Ed Taylor - Alex Rodriguez - 3B, NYY
- Brian Hoyle - Ryan Howard - 1B, PHI
- Nathan Peiffer - Ryan Braun - OF, MIL
- David Wilsher - Prince Fielder - 1B, MIL
- Yoram Batner - David Wright - 3B, NYM
- Tony Cincotta - Tim Lincecum - SP, SF
- Scott Gilroy - Mark Teixeira - 1B, NYY
- Tad Blooth - Matt Kemp - OF, LAD
- Ben Santos - Joe Mauer - C, MIN
Round 2 - View Comments
- Ben Santos - Troy Tulowitzki - SS, COL
- Tad Blooth - Evan Longoria - 3B, TB
- Scott Gilroy - Ian Kinsler - 2B, TEX
- Tony Cincotta - Jimmy Rollins - SS, PHI
- Yoram Batner - Jacoby Ellsbury - OF, BOS
- David Wilsher - Mark Reynolds - 3B ARI
- Nathan Peiffer - Jose Reyes - SS, NYM
- Brian Hoyle - Matt Holliday - OF, FA
- Ed Taylor - Adrain Gonzalez - 1B, SD
- Jim Halberg - Victor Martinez - C/1B, BOS
- Dan Kercher - Felix Hernandez - SP, SEA
- Dennis Page - Ryan Zimmerman - 3B, WAS
- Rick Hoffman - Grady Sizemore - OF, CLE
- Harrell Kirstein - Justin Upton - OF, ARI
Round 3 - View Comments
- Harrell Kirstein - Pablo Sadoval - 3B, SF
- Rick Hoffman - Joey Votto - 1B, CIN
- Dennis Page - Justin Morneau - 1B, MIN
- Dan Kercher - Zack Greinke - SP, KC
- Jim Halberg - Adam Lind - OF, TOR
- Ed Taylor - Brian Roberts - 2B, BAL
- Brian Hoyle - Aaron Hill - 2B, TOR
- Nathan Peiffer - CC Sabathia - SP, NYY
- David Wilsher - Dustin Pedroia - 2B, BOS
- Yoram Batner - Jason Bay - OF, BOS
- Tony Cincotta - Kevin Youkilis - 1B, BOS
- Scott Gilroy - Ichiro Suzuki - OF, SEA
- Tad Blooth - Nick Markakis - OF, BAL
- Ben Santos - Roy Halladay - SP, TOR
Round 4 - View Comments
- Ben Santos - Curtis Granderson - OF, NYY
- Tad Blooth - Andre Ethier - OF, LAD
- Scott Gilroy - Derek Jeter - SS, NYY
- Tony Cincotta - Robinson Cano - 2B, NYY
- Yoram Batner - Dan Haren - SP, ARI
- David Wilsher - Justin Verlander - SP, DET
- Nathan Peiffer - Kendry Morales - 1B, LAA
- Brian Hoyle - Cliff Lee - SP, PHI
- Ed Taylor - Shane Victorino - OF, PHI
- Jim Halberg - Johan Santana - SP, NYM
- Dan Kercher - Adam Wainwright - SP, STL
- Dennis Page - Jayson Werth - OF, PHI
- Rick Hoffman - Brandon Phillips - 2B, CIN
- Harrell Kirstein - Adam Dunn - OF, WAS
Round 5 - View Comments
- Harrell Kirstein - Josh Johnson - SP, FLA
- Rick Hoffman - Brian McCann - C, ATL
- Dennis Page - Jake Peavy - SP, CHW
- Dan Kercher - Jon Lester - SP, BOS
- Jim Halberg - B.J. Upton - OF, TB
- Ed Taylor - Manny Ramirez - OF, LAD
- Brian Hoyle - Mariano Rivera - RP, NYY
- Nathan Peiffer - Ben Zobrist - 2B, TB
- David Wilsher - Carlos Beltran - OF, NYM
- Yoram Batner - Josh Hamilton - OF, TEX
- Tony Cincotta - Billy Bitler - 1B, KC
- Scott Gilroy - Bobby Abreu - OF, LAA
- Tad Blooth - Adam Jones - OF, BAL
- Ben Santos - Carlos Pena - 1B, TB
Round 6 - View Comments
- Ben Santos - Nelson Cruz - OF, TEX
- Tad Blooth - Matt Cain - SP, SF
- Scott Gilroy - Josh Beckett - SP, BOS
- Tony Cincotta - Matt Wieters - C, BAL
- Yoram Batner - Lance Berkman - 1B, HOU
- David Wilsher - Javier Vazquez - SP, ATL
- Nathan Peiffer - Shin-Soo Choo - OF, CLE
- Brian Hoyle - Aramis Ramirez - 3B, CHC
- Ed Taylor - Chris Carpenter - SP, STL
- Jim Halberg - Carlos Lee - OF, HOU
- Dan Kercher - Michael Bourn - OF, HOU
- Dennis Page - Clayton Kershaw - SP, LAD
- Rick Hoffman - Jonathan Papelbon - RP, BOS
- Harrell Kirstein - Jose Lopez - 2B, SEA
Round 7 - View Comments
- Harrell Kirstein - Alfonso Soriano - OF, CHC
- Rick Hoffman - Jonathan Broxton - RP, LAD
- Dennis Page - Rajah Davis - OF, OAK
- Dan Kercher - Michael Cuddyer - OF, MIN
- Jim Halberg - Gordon Beckham - 3B, CHW
- Ed Taylor - Joe Nathan - RP, MIN
- Brian Hoyle - Alex Rios - OF, CHW
- Nathan Peiffer - Chone Figgins - 3B, SEA
- David Wilsher - Hunter Pence - OF, HOU
- Yoram Batner - Derreck Lee - 1B, CHC
- Tony Cincotta - Francisco Rodriguez - RP, NYM
- Scott Gilroy - Ricky Nolasco - SP, FLA
- Tad Blooth - John Lackey - SP, BOS
- Ben Santos - Raul Ibanez - OF, PHI
Round 8 - View Comments
- Ben Santos - Dan Uggla - 2B, FLA
- Tad Blooth - Jay Bruce - OF, CIN
- Scott Gilroy - Carlos Quentin - OF, CHW
- Tony Cincotta - Tommy Hanson - SP, ATL
- Yoram Batner - Torii Hunter - OF, LAA
- David Wilsher - Yovani Gallardo - SP, MIL
- Nathan Peiffer - Andrew McCutchen - OF, PIT
- Brian Hoyle - Yunel Escobar - SS, ATL
- Ed Taylor - Jason Kubel - OF, MIN
- Jim Halberg - Cole Hamels - SP, PHI
- Dan Kercher - Jair Jurrejens - SP, ATL
- Dennis Page - Brandon Webb - SP, ARI
- Rick Hoffman - Michael Young - 3B, TEX
- Harrell Kirstein - Ubaldo Jimenez - SP, COL
Round 9 - View comments
- Harrell Kirstein - Asdrubel Cabrera - SS, CLE
- Rick Hoffman - Nate McLouth - ATL, OF
- Dennis Page - Elvis Andrus - SS, TEX
- Dan Kercher - Carlos Gonzalez - OF, COL
- Jim Halberg - Heath Bell - RP, SD
- Ed Taylor - Brad Hawpe - OF, COL
- Brian Hoyle - Rafael Furcal - SS, LAD
- Nathan Peiffer - Joakim Soria - RP, KC
- David Wilsher - Alexei Ramirez - SS, CHW
- Yoram Batner - Jorge Posada - C, NYY
- Tony Cincotta - Geovany Soto - C, CHC
- Scott Gilroy - Ian Stewart - 3B, COL
- Tad Blooth - Stephen Drew - SS, ARI
- Ben Santos - Chad Billingsley - SP, LAD
Round 10 - View comments
- Ben Santos - Neftali Feliz - RP, TEX
- Tad Blooth - Nyjer Morgan - OF, WAS
- Scott Gilroy - Huston Street - RP, COL
- Tony Cincotta - Matt Garza - SP, TB
- Yoram Batner - Jason Bartlett - SS, TB
- David Wilsher - Brian Fuentes - RP, LAA
- Nathan Peiffer - Brian Wilson - RP, SF
- Brian Hoyle - Russell Martin - C, LAD
- Ed Taylor - Vlad Guerrero - DH, LAA
- Jim Halberg - James Shields - SP, TB
- Dan Kercher - Denard Span - OF, MIN
- Dennis Page - Juan Pierre - OF, CHW
- Rick Hoffman - Jared Weaver - SP, LAA
- Harrell Kirstein - Wandy Rodriguez - SP, HOU
Round 11 - View Comments
- Harrell Kirstein - Johnny Damon - OF, fa
- Rick Hoffman - A.J. Burnett - SP, NYY
- Dennis Page - David Aardsma - RP, SEA
- Dan Kercher - Franklin Gutierrez - OF, SEA
- Jim Halberg - Francisco Cordero - RP, CIN
- Ed Taylor - Chipper Jones - 3B, ATL
- Brian Hoyle - Roy Oswalt - SP, HOU
- Nathan Peiffer - Nick Swisher - OF, NYY
- David Wilsher - Ryan Ludwick - OF, STL
- Yoram Batner - Howie Kendrick - 2B, LAA
- Tony Cincotta - Rafael Soriano - RP, TB
- Scott Gilroy - Martin Prado - 2B, ATL
- Tad Blooth - Max Scherzer - SP, DET
- Ben Santos - Jose Valverde - RP, HOU
Round 12 - View Comments
- Ben Santos - Ted Lilly - SP, CHC
- Tad Blooth - Mark Buehrle - SP, CHW
- Scott Gilroy - Scott Baker - SP, MIN
- Tony Cincotta - Brett Anderson - SP, OAK
- Yoram Batner - Billy Wagner - RP, ATL
- David Wilsher - Corey Hart - OF, MIL
- Nathan Peiffer - Edwin Jackson - SP, ARI
- Brian Hoyle - Magglio Ordonez - OF, DET
- Ed Taylor - Carlos Zambrano - SP, CHC
- Jim Halberg - Garrett Jones - 1B/OF, PIT
- Dan Kercher - Andrew Bailey - RP, OAK
- Dennis Page - Chris Coghlan - OF, FLA
- Rick Hoffman - John Danks - SP, CHW
- Harrell Kirstein - Kurt Suzuki - C, OAK
Round 13 - View Comments
- Harrell Kirstein - Alex Gordon - 3B, KC
- Rick Hoffman - Ryan Dempster - SP, CHC
- Dennis Page - Casey Mcgehee - 2B/3B, MIL
- Dan Kercher - Julio Borbon - OF, TEX
- Jim Halberg - Miguel Montero - C, ARI
- Ed Taylor - Mike Napoli - C, LAA
- Brian Hoyle - Carlos Marmol - RP, CHC
- Nathan Peiffer - Ryan Doumit - C, PIT
- David Wilsher - Trevor Hoffman - RP, MIL
- Yoram Batner - Gavin Floyd - SP, CHW
- Tony Cincotta - Everth Cabrera - SS, SD
- Scott Gilroy - Chris Davis - 1B, TEX
- Tad Blooth - Rickie Weeks - 2B, MIL
- Ben Santos - Miguel Tejada - SS, fa
Round 14 - View comments
- Ben Santos - Jorge Cantu - 3B, FLA
- Tad Blooth - Scott Kazmir - SP, LAA
- Scott Gilroy - Tim Hudson - SP, ATL
- Tony Cincotta - David Ortiz - DH, BOS
- Yoram Batner - David Price - SP, TB
- David Wilsher - Rich Harden - SP, TEX
- Nathan Peiffer - Daisuke Matsuzaka - SP, BOS
- Brian Hoyle - James Loney - 1B, LAD
- Ed Taylor - Ryan Franklin - RP, STL
- Jim Halberg - Erick Aybar - SS, LAA
- Dan Kercher - Alcides Escobar - SS, MIL
- Dennis Page - Jonathan Sanchez - SP, SF
- Rick Hoffman - Bengie Molina - C, NYM
- Harrell Kirstein - Frank Francisco - RP, TEX
Round 15 - View Comments
- Harrell Kirstein - Jorge de la Rosa - SP, COL
- Rick Hoffman - Colby Rasmus - OF, STL
- Dennis Page - Leo Nunez - RP, FLA
- Dan Kercher - Yadier Molina - C, STL
- Jim Halberg - Johnny Peralta - 3B/SS, CLE
- Ed Taylor - Chris Iannetta - C, COL
- Brian Hoyle - Mark DeRosa - OF/3B, SF
- Nathan Peiffer - Kevin Slowey - SP, MIN
- David Wilsher - Brad Lidge - RP, PHI
- Yoram Batner - Bobby Jenks - RP, CHW
- Tony Cincotta - Drew Stubbs - OF, CIN
- Scott Gilroy - Mike Gonzalez - RP, BAL
- Tad Blooth - J.J. Hardy - SS, MIN
- Ben Santos - Adrian Beltre - 3B, BOS
Round 16 - View Comments
- Ben Santos - Matt Capps - RP, WAS
- Tad Blooth - Paul Konerko - 1B, CHW
- Scott Gilroy - Cody Ross - OF, FLA
- Tony Cincotta - Mike Cameron - OF, BOS
- Yoram Batner - Clay Buchholz - SP, BOS
- David Wilsher - Ryan Theriot - SS, CHC
- Nathan Peiffer - Johnny Cueto - SP, CIN
- Brian Hoyle - Derek Lowe - SP, ATL
- Ed Taylor - J.A. Happ - SP, PHI
- Jim Halberg - Jermaine Dye - OF, fa
- Dan Kercher - Joba Chamberlain - SP, NYY
- Dennis Page - A.J. Pierzynski - C, CHW
- Rick Hoffman - Randy Wolf - SP, MIL
- Harrell Kirstein - Andy Pettite - SP, NYY
Round 17 - View Comments
- Harrell Kirstein - Chad Qualls - RP, ARI
- Rick Hoffman - Ervin Santana - SP, LAA
- Dennis Page - Seth Smith - OF, COL
- Dan Kercher - John Baker - C, FLA
- Jim Halberg - Vernon Wells - OF, TOR
- Ed Taylor - Kerry Wood - RP, CLE
- Brian Hoyle - Milton Bradley - OF, SEA
- Nathan Peiffer - Buster Posey - C, SF
- David Wilsher - Randy Wells - SP, CHC
- Yoram Batner - Travis Snider - OF, TOR
- Tony Cincotta - Chase Headley - OF, SD
- Scott Gilroy - Dexter Fowler - OF, COL
- Tad Blooth - Matt Lindstrom - RP, HOU
- Ben Santos - Jack Cust - OF, OAK
Round 18 - View Comments
- Ben Santos - Rick Porcello - SP, DET
- Tad Blooth - Scott Downs - RP, TOR
- Scott Gilroy - Jeff Neimann - SP, TB
- Tony Cincotta - Jake Fox - 3B/OF, OAK
- Yoram Batner - Kelly Johnson - 2B, ARI
- David Wilsher - Todd Helton - 1B, COL
- Nathan Peiffer - Matt LaPorta - OF, CLE
- Brian Hoyle - Chris Young - OF, ARI
- Ed Taylor - Joe Saunders - SP, LAA
- Jim Halberg - Carlos Gomez - OF, MIL
- Dan Kercher - Marco Scutaro - SS, BOS
- Dennis Page - Joel Hanrahan - RP, PIT
- Rick Hoffman - Nolan Reimold - OF, BAL
- Harrell Kirstein - Juan Rivera - OF, LAA
Round 19 - View Comments
- Harrell Kirstein - Erik Bedard - SP, fa
- Rick Hoffman - Jason Heyward - OF, ATL
- Dennis Page - Francisco Liriano - SP, MIN
- Dan Kercher - Placido Polanco - 2B, PHI
- Jim Halberg - Joe Blanton - SP, PHI
- Ed Taylor - Macier Izturis - SS, LAA
- Brian Hoyle - Carlos Ruiz - C, PHI
- Nathan Peiffer - Adam LaRoche - 1B, ARI
- David Wilsher - Kelly Shoppach - C, TB
- Yoram Batner - Aaron Harang - SP, CIN
- Tony Cincotta - Luke Scott - OF, BAL
- Scott Gilroy - Hideki Matsui - DH, LAA
- Tad Blooth - Stephen Straburg - SP, WAS
- Ben Santos - Josh Willingham - OF, WAS
Round 20
- Ben Santos - Ben Sheets - SP, fa
- Tad Blooth - Jason Frasor - RP, TOR
- Scott Gilroy - Jesus Flores - C, WAS *
- Tony Cincotta - Brett Myers - SP, HOU
- Yoram Batner - Hiroki Kuroda - SP, LAD
- David Wilsher - Brett Gardner - OF, NYY
- Nathan Peiffer - Phil Hughes - RP, NYY
- Brian Hoyle - Kyle Lohse - SP, STL
- Ed Taylor - Scott Feldman - SP, TEX
- Jim Halberg - Octavio Dotel - RP, PIT
- Dan Kercher - Nick Johnson - 1B, NYY
- Dennis Page - Felipe Lopez - 2B, MIL
- Rick Hoffman - Chris Getz - 2B, KC
- Harrell Kirstein - Lasting Milledge - OF, PIT
Round 21
- Harrell Kirstein - Jordan Zimmerman - SP, WAS
- Rick Hoffman - Homer Bailey - SP, CIN
- Dennis Page - Conor Jackson - OF, ARI
- Dan Kercher - Ryan Madson - RP, PHI
- Jim Halberg - Brad Penny - SP, STL
- Ed Taylor - Freddy Sanchez - 2B, SF
- Brian Hoyle - Bronson Arroyo - SP, CIN
- Nathan Peiffer - Drew Storen - RP, WAS
- David Wilsher - Jeff Francouer - OF, NYM
- Yoram Batner - Cameron Maybin - OF, FLA
- Tony Cincotta - Vincente Padilla - SP, LAD
- Scott Gilroy - Trevor Cahill - SP, OAK
- Tad Blooth - Carlos Santana - C, CLE
- Ben Santos - Justin Masterson - SP, CLE
Round 22
- Ben Santos - Scott Podsednik - OF, KC
- Tad Blooth - Lou Marson - C, CLE
- Scott Gilroy - Ramon Hernandez - C, CIN
- Tony Cincotta - Joey Devine - RP, OAK
- Yoram Batner - Brian Matusz - SP, BAL
- David Wilsher - Wade Davis - SP, TB
- Nathan Peiffer - Mark Teahan - 3B/OF, CHW
- Brian Hoyle - John Maine - SP, NYM
- Ed Taylor - Jeff francis - SP, COL
- Jim Halberg - Aubrey Huff - 1B, SF
- Dan Kercher - Scott Rolen - 3B, CIN
- Dennis Page - Alex Avila - C, DET
- Rick Hoffman - Kyle Blanks - OF, SD
- Harrell Kirstein - Edwin Encarnacion - 3B, TOR
Round 23
- Harrell Kirstein - Miguel Olivo - C, COL
- Rick Hoffman - Ian Desmond - SS, WAS
- Dennis Page - Joel Piniero - SP, LAA
- Dan Kercher - J.P. Howell - RP, TB
- Jim Halberg - Colby Lewis - SP, TEX
- Ed Taylor - Matt Joyce - OF, TB
- Brian Hoyle - Dany Baez - RP, PHI
- Nathan Peiffer - eric Young Jr. - 2B, COL
- David Wilsher - Nick Hundley - C, SD
- Yoram Batner - Gregg Zaun - C, MIL
- Tony Cincotta - Carlos Guillen - OF, DET
- Scott Gilroy - Kris Medlin, RP, ATL
- Tad Blooth - Casey Blake - 3B, LAD
- Ben Santos - Jarrod Saltalamachia - C, TEX


[…] 2010 Fantasy Baseball Mock Draft […]
Anyone else feel Crawford was taken too early here? Jacoby Ellsbury will have a better year in a better lineup and will still be available in the late second round or so. Overall, I feel Crawford is overrated if considered any earlier than round 2.
only 6 players in and it looks like it’s going to be a long haul….I agree with kelly, please let’s move it along….especially in the early rounds!
@Dan, I agree with you. I not sure that Crawford is over-rated as much as I think that the only way he justifies a 4th over-all pick is by hitting all of his upside. He is talented enough to do it but the only thing he can do at that pick is meet your expectations or disappoint you.
Crawford ranked 5th on the ESPN Player Rater (5×5) last year. So he has proven the ability to produce at that level, the question is how likely one feels he is to repeat or improve.
I’d prefer Braun or Kemp in the OF there, but I don’t think it was a bad pick in any way.
Kercher, after 4 rounds your best and only offensive player is Crawford… How do you expect to keep up with the Joneses?
Halladay going last in 3rd round is a joke (great pick). If anybody bothered to draft SP you would have dominated this league. Santana late in the 4th? He didn’t have elbow or shoulder surgery. I’m seeing reaches as everywhere with great/solid pitchers just sitting there. Anybody hear of Tommy Hanson? How the heck Nolasco go first?
@Mike…. Seriously?!? You don’t consider removing bone chips from an elbow a surgery? You must be from Atlanta to think that Tommy Hanson deserves to be selected by the 6th round. I would love to know where you would draft him, or where you would rank him among starting pitchers.
I am not sure what strategy you use, but selecting a ton of pitching early has yet to ever work for me.
Looking at Nolasco’s O9 residuals He was dominant after returning from a brief Triple-A exile, with a five-to-one K/BB and 10.1 K/9 ratio in his last 22 starts (Via Cory Schwartz) . Looks like potential ace with a little development.
I’ll take Nolasco next year over Hanson, too. Hanson is going to be a really good pitcher but he wouldn’t be the first great one to take a step back after a big rookie first impression. Nolasco pitched to some really bad luck last year and if he can limit his disaster starts he will step right into that second tier of starters.